If you want your interior to be comfortable and stylish, you should not only choose high-quality furniture and decor, but also make all surfaces modern and functional. Today, high demands are placed on decoration in terms of safety and reliability, as well as durability and attractiveness of appearance. Therefore, disputes about which is better - a stretch ceiling or drywall, do not subside among specialists to this day.
In order to make a choice, these types of finishes should be considered for several factors. But both have high soundproofing, strength and durability. With the help of such technologies, it is possible to create multilevel extraordinary compositions. Sometimes the right solution is found for each specific room.
Ease of work
If you still do not know which ceiling is drywall or stretch, to choose, you should consider them for the simplicity of the work. This is where we start. According to experts, it is not possible to install a stretch ceiling without special equipment. But even if there is a heat gun, the installation will be quite complicated and will require certain skills, as well as accuracy.
As for the drywall construction, its installation can be done on its own using simple tools. But for work it is better to invite an assistant, since the drywall sheets have an impressive width, so it will be quite difficult to raise them. If you act on your own, you can even break the canvas.
Do I need to free the room
If you still think which ceilings are better - stretch or plasterboard, then you should consider the factor whether there is a need to free up the room during installation. For example, during the installation of the first option, construction debris and dust are almost not formed. From the room it will be necessary to take out only objects that do not cope well with the effects of high temperature. But when installing a plasterboard ceiling, the removal of furniture cannot be avoided.
Speed ββof work
If you cannot decide for yourself which ceiling to make - stretch or plasterboard, then you should consider these two types of finishes also in terms of speed of work. How long will the mount take? The simplest single-level tensioning systems are installed in 4 hours. To install a plasterboard ceiling, you need at least 2 days. The final time will depend on the characteristics of the premises and the complexity of the design.
Final ceiling height
When a baguette for fixing the ceiling is fixed, about 4 cm is lost. This value may turn out to be larger, which depends on the presence of communications passing under the canvas. But the distance between the drywall and the base ceiling is unlikely to be less than 10 cm. This factor must be taken into account when working in rooms with low ceilings.
Built-in backlight and care. Feedback
When the owners of an apartment or house decide what is best - a stretch ceiling or drywall, they read consumer reviews quite often. You too can follow suit. After reading the opinions, you can understand that the wiring and recessed fixtures are installed without any problems. For point light sources for stretch ceilings, there is a huge range of plates, hotmelt adhesives, glasses that make the process safe. This suggests that the built-in backlight has a place to be when installing a plasterboard system or stretch ceiling. There are no winners here.
But on the issue of care, as the hostesses believe, PVC-fabric requires minimal effort. Every few months, dry cleaning will be necessary. Once every six months, you can do wet cleaning. Drywall ceiling requires updating from time to time.
Damage resistance
PVC film may be damaged by a sharp, hard object. Even children's toys can cause damage to her, as well as furniture corners during rearrangement. If you stick the puncture site, it will reduce the visual attractiveness and nullify the effect of water resistance. But in the case of a suspended structure, it is much more difficult to damage it, but it is still not worth throwing heavy objects up.
Fire and Flood Resistance
Both coatings show good results in terms of fire resistance. They are not flammable, but exposure to fire will definitely damage them. Polyvinyl chloride stretch ceilings withstand about 100 liters of fluid per square meter. If the flood occurred, you only need to wait for the master to drain the liquid and restore the original appearance. But drywall with such an impact irrevocably lose its appearance.
Service life and design
If you properly operate the PVC film, then it will be ready to last up to a quarter of a century. But plasterboard coatings are installed with a 10-year warranty, but it will be necessary to update the finish more often. As for the design, modern stretch ceilings have any color. They can be glossy, matte, velvet or decorated with photo printing, as well as ornament. Suspended structures you can arrange on your own. Ceiling plates, paint and wallpaper are usually used for this. But to create the effect of a mirror surface still does not work.
Price competition
Quite often, consumers decide whether the ceiling is cheaper - stretch or plasterboard. Suspension design will cost you about 210 rubles per square meter. The final cost will depend on the ambitions and the installers, as well as the location. When installing tension systems, the spread in prices will be wider. The cost can vary from 70 to 700 rubles. Everything will depend on the type, texture and color of the material, as well as the prices for the work and the manufacturer. A canvas with photo printing will cost you more than a single-color one.
More details about the cost
In order to have an idea of ββhow much the described options for finishing the ceiling will cost, it is necessary to carry out approximate calculations by comparing the final cost. If you have a room of 20 meters around the perimeter and an area of ββ25 m2, then the average amounts will be as follows. The cost of an inexpensive film is about 600 rubles. per square meter. This includes the cost of all additional materials for installation, but installation is not included, as well as laying under the chandelier, as well as bypassing pipes with utilities. These items can add up to 1000 rubles. to the end result. You will also pay extra for fixtures if they are installed. The final amount will be approximately 16,000 rubles. The necessary number of lighting devices, or rather, their installation, should be added here.
If itβs important for you to decide which is cheaper - a stretch ceiling or drywall, then you should consider the last option. If the same room is considered in the example, then you will pay about 350 rubles. per square meter. This does not include the cost of decoration, which will add about 350 rubles. per square. It is necessary to take into account other components. For example, the base under the chandelier, the installation of wiring and fixtures. As a result, the price will be 18,500 rubles. But this is true if 1000 rubles are added to the amount. for installing wiring and laying communications for one chandelier.
Comparison of the cost of plasterboard ceilings with stretch and plastered. Features
If you want to know which is cheaper - drywall, plaster or suspended ceiling, you should understand this issue in more detail. So let's get started! Based on the above calculations, we can conclude that the tension system is still cheaper than the plasterboard ceiling. Therefore, at cost it is better to compare plaster and PVC film.
If the main selection criterion is cost, then it may seem that stucco is a budget solution. But this is true only for one case - when you plan to carry out the work yourself. This process will be tedious and long, but materials and components are sold at affordable prices.
When you know what is cheaper - a stretch ceiling or drywall, the 1st coating option can be compared with plaster. After completion of work, it will have to be updated every two years. Everything will depend on how quickly the surface gets dirty. Everything becomes complicated if the neighbors from above arrange a flood. From this we can conclude that stretch ceilings are more expensive than plaster, but the price is compensated by the long service life.
If a quality coating is installed, it will retain its original appearance for several decades. Stretch ceilings will be able to withstand a large amount of water per square meter, thereby saving repairs and furniture when flooding from above.
Installation of suspended ceilings is carried out quite quickly, while using a well-functioning scheme. This allows you to quickly form a finishing surface, and additionally wallpapering or staining it is not necessary. It is impossible to get a ready-made ceiling by plastering in 2 hours, as is the case with tension structures. From this the conclusion suggests itself that there is no single answer. If we consider the issue from the point of view of lump sum costs, then the plaster will be cheaper, but in the future, a stretch ceiling due to durability and practicality will save money and strength. That is, it is better to stay on it. You know that it is cheaper - a stretch ceiling or drywall. The first system will not hit your pocket so much, and in the case of plaster you will have to pay even less. However, further expenses with this finish may increase.
Finally
Quite often, consumers decide whether it is cheaper - a stretch ceiling or drywall. You too may be among them. If the choice depends only on the cost, then you should choose a stretch ceiling. When the budget is very limited, you can use the technology of applying plaster. If you can carry out the work yourself, then specialists will not have to pay for the work.