Reviews for the 2005 Brokeback Mountain movie are pretty controversial. And not surprising, because this is one of the first paintings that touched on the topic of love between two men. As a result, it was perceived by the viewer very ambiguously. In the story, people are told about the complex relationship between a cowboy and an assistant rancher. Heroes meet and understand that they cannot exist without each other.
Story line
The action takes place in the United States in the sixties. At seasonal work, Del Mar gets to know Jack Twist. They both grew up on a poor ranch. They were hired by simple shepherds of sheep near Brokeback Mountain. One night the heroes drink a lot of whiskey. It was cold outside, and the characters decided to hide from the weather in a tent. In it, an intimate relationship arises between Delo and Jack. After that, the love relationships of the heroes begin.
Having finished summer work, the couple parted. Del marries his girlfriend, after which they have several children. Jack is leaving for another state to participate in a rodeo. After that, the hero meets the girl with whom he has a child. However, family life weighs on him. One day, the hero receives a postcard from his ex-boyfriend. After this begins a tense narrative of impossible love between men.
The Brokeback Mountain movie: actors and roles
Initially, the director offered Brad Pitt and Leonardo DiCaprio to star in this work. However, the actors refused to participate in the filming. Since it was considered that the movie will badly affect their reputation. Actors and roles in the film:
- Jake Gyllenhaal. Starred Jack Twist.
- Heath Ledger. He starred in the lead role of Del Mara.
- Minor Characters. Graham Beckel played News. Randy Quaid in the movie Joe. Michelle Williams was the wife of Del Mara. Anne Hathaway played the role of Jack Twist's chosen one.
Thanks to this composition, the work received the Oscar. Since the actors gave all their best. In addition, they really got used to the role. As a result, the viewer perceives all emotions as true and wants to empathize with the heroes.
Reviews of the Russian viewer
For people who live in the CIS, the topic of love relationships between two men is perceived negatively. However, there are viewers who liked this movie. Reviews for the movie "Brokeback Mountain":
- The opinion of the girls. Most of the fairer sex reacted to the work tolerantly. They believe that the cast has done its job of portraying love between men. In addition to acting in films, a good camera work. The creators showed nature on a large scale and selected the appropriate music for the picture. Reviews about the movie "Brokeback Mountain" from the girls are mostly positive. They were able to feel the atmosphere of forbidden love.
- The opinion of men. Guys believe that the work is worthy, but very difficult to understand. It is unpleasant to watch him because of the propaganda of homosexuality. Most Russian men changed their opinion about the actors in a negative direction.
- Some spectators were hooked by the picture so much that the guys began to regret watching the work. However, there are also positive reviews about the movie Brokeback Mountain. Since it had a good camera work. The creators remarkably reflected the nature of the cowboy. Basically, everyone does not like the theme of love between men.
The film "Brokeback Mountain" in 2005 made a very vivid impression on the viewer. Especially on the CIS public. Despite the negative feedback, his rating on popular resources does not fall below 7 points out of 10. You can watch the movie for people who are tolerant of all orientations.
Foreign viewer reviews
Due to the fact that the work was released in 2005, a lot of people took it negatively. At this time, even a foreign society was not ready for such films. However, he collected more positive ratings. People believe that this work can amaze to the core. It can be reviewed several times. In addition, the actors got used to their roles well.
Viewers believe that paying attention to the orientation of the heroes is not worth it. Since the film should be appreciated for other reasons. The director well conveyed all the landscapes and beauty so strongly that the viewer has a desire to be near nature.
In addition, in the work there are several unexpected turns of events that cause vivid emotions in the viewer. The film was shot about physical strength, friendships and love relationships. It conveys feelings that you will never meet in the real world.
Opinion of professional critics
Most viewers believe that the work has a very serious and complex history. Reviews of film critics about the movie "Brokeback Mountain" emphasize that he is not about love relationships between men. Director Ang Lee showed a story that is very close to the reality of modern man. The creator said that the fate of the guys is doomed to hard work, maintenance of the family and hilarious routine.
However, not everyone can understand the complexity of the situation. Especially at a time when the film was just released. People in 2019 perceive the work easier. Since now society is tolerant of all minorities. In this film, the director showed what “forbidden love” can be. In addition, critics note that the acting in the work is at a high level. Critics were also attracted by the work of the operator. Again, for how he beautifully reflected the atmosphere and landscapes of the area. Film critics rate the film 8/10 points.
Negative reviews
Some people were disappointed after watching this work. Dissatisfied viewers believe that the significance of this work is overrated by the public. There is nothing but the forbidden topic of love and good cast. The picture does not describe the serious experiences of the heroes, it does not have drama and deep meanings.
This is due to the fact that two men just came to work part-time. The director did not make any allusions to the close relationship between them. Since the heroes practically did not communicate with each other. They had nothing to tie them together. Even a small friendship between them did not arise. However, this did not stop the heroes from making love. This is what most intolerant viewers don’t like.
The scenes shown in the film are not able to touch. Heath Ledger poorly accustomed to his role. However, Jake Gyllenhaal succeeded. In negative reviews, people say that Michelle Williams played well in this piece. It was the secondary character that conveyed the pain of men's love.
Conclusion
Not every person needs to watch this work. Especially if he is abhorrent to the idea of relations between men. However, a person’s picture can cause emotions that he never had. If the viewer has a well-developed sense of empathy, then he will be able to immerse himself in the whole atmosphere of this work.