The analogue of "Karsila". Which is better: Karsil or Essential?

Means "Karsil" is a herbal medicine containing biologically active components obtained from milk thistle plants. This drug protects the liver from the harmful effects. Today, the main points regarding the Karsil medication will be considered: instructions, analogues, side effects, price, storage and sale conditions. Separately, we’ll analyze another remedy - the Essential drug. This is an analogue of the drug "Karsil", which, incidentally, is actively advertised on television. We will find out what are the advantages and disadvantages of this medication, and also determine which of the two drugs is better for the patient to choose.

carzil analog

The drug "Karsil": indications

This remedy is prescribed to patients in such cases:

  • To prevent toxic liver damage, if a person takes medications for a long time, alcohol.
  • Conditions after already suffered hepatitis.
  • Cirrhosis of the liver.
  • Non-viral chronic hepatitis.
  • With toxic liver damage.

Medication structure

The drug "Karsil", the composition of which is indicated on the package, is a biconvex dragee of brown color, odorless. This medication includes the following components:

  • The active substance is silymarin - 35 mg.
  • Additional elements - wheat starch, lactose monohydrate, talc, povidone, microcrystalline cellulose, magnesium stearate, sorbitol, sodium bicarbonate.

Means "Karsil", the composition of which was described above, is packaged in blisters of 10 tablets in each.

Mode of application

This medication for children after 12 years of age, as well as adults, must be taken orally by 1-2 tablets three times a day. In severe cases, the doctor may double the dose. The duration of therapy is usually at least 3 months.

Karsil instructions for use analogues

Contraindications

This medication should not be taken in such situations:

  • With increased sensitivity to the components of the drug.
  • During acute intoxication.
  • Children under 12 years old.
  • Women in position, as well as breast-feeding mothers.

Side effects from the drug "Karsil"

This remedy can cause adverse events such as:

  • Nausea.
  • Diarrhea.
  • Rash.
  • Alopecia.
  • Itchy skin.
  • Dyspepsia.

Overdose

If a person accidentally took the “Carsil” medicine (the price, the analogues of which will be discussed later), then the patient should definitely take measures to prevent his condition from worsening. To do this, immediately induce vomiting, gastric lavage, take activated charcoal or Enterosgel and provide yourself with peace of mind for a while.

which is better karsil or essentiale

Analogs of the drug "Karsil"

This medicine has many prototypes that can be purchased at any pharmacy. And these are such drugs as Essentiale, Silegon, Silibor, Silymarin, Phosphogliv, Rosilimarin. However, the most important analogue of the medicine, which the article is devoted to, is the Essential drug.

Therefore, since we have already considered all questions regarding such a tool as “Karsil” - instructions for use, analogues, the price of this drug, it will now be appropriate to disassemble its main prototype. Moreover, it is no worse than the medication to which the article is devoted, and even surpasses it in some respects.

Storage, sale conditions

The drug "Karsil" is available without a doctor's prescription. The medication should be stored in a dry place, protected from the sun, and also where children can not get. Permissible storage temperature - not higher than 25 degrees. The shelf life of this product is 24 months.

karsil price analogues

The drug "Karsil" and "Karsil forte" - what is the difference?

The composition of the tablets of the second medication contains a larger amount of active substance. Many experts prescribe the drug "Karsil" for preventive purposes. It is most convenient to do this when using a medication of prolonged action called "Carsil forte."

According to the instructions, Karsil tablets should be taken 3 times a day. This is not very convenient for people who work during the day, and they simply can forget to drink this remedy. And the medication “Karsil forte” was created for the comfort of patients, since you need to take the medicine only in the morning and in the evening. That is, a person woke up - took a remedy, after work came - drank a second dose of the drug.

The drug "Karsil forte": similar drugs

This medication has several analogues. These are such drugs as Silimar, Silimarin, Legalon, Silibor, Darsil. All these medicines can be a worthy substitute for the “Carsil forte” remedy. Analogues of this drug also contain silymarin as the main substance. Some of the aforementioned similar tools are cheaper, while others are on a par with it.

The cost of the medicine "Karsil" and "Karsil forte"

The price of the first medicine is quite acceptable and will be affordable for any resident of our country. So, for a package of 30 capsules, you will have to pay about 270 rubles. For the drug "Karsil forte" will need to give a little more - 290 rubles for 30 tablets.

karsil composition

The drug "Essential": indications for use

Doctors can prescribe this analogue of Karsil, a medication prescribed for various liver problems, for such ailments:

  • Hepatitis in both acute and chronic form.
  • Fatty liver degeneration (including diabetes).
  • Hepatic coma.
  • Cirrhosis, necrosis of liver cells.
  • Psoriasis.
  • Toxic liver damage, including toxicosis during pregnancy.
  • Neurodermatitis.
  • Radiation syndrome.

Release form

The Essentiale product, an analogue of Karsil, a drug that has more contraindications, is sold in pharmacies in two forms:

  1. In the form of capsules.
  2. In the form of ampoules for injection.

Composition of Essential

This analogue of "Karsil" - a medicine, by the way, quite popular - includes such components:

  1. 1 capsule contains: active substance - essential phospholipids. Auxiliary elements: solid fat, soy and castor oil, ethanol, dyes.
  2. The following components are included in the 1 ampoule of the Essential drug: the active substance is essential phospholipids. Excipients are other than in the capsule, and these are: benzyl alcohol, disoxycholic acid, sodium chloride, sodium hydroxide, riboflavin, water for injection.

The use of capsules "Essential"

This analogue of "Karsil" - a medicine that is available only in the form of capsules, doctors can prescribe for both children and adults. Usually the first dose is 2 capsules three times a day. As maintenance therapy - 1 capsule 3 times a day. You need to take medicine while eating. It is forbidden to chew dragees, they only need to be swallowed with a small amount of water.

karsil instructions analogues

The use of intravenous injections "Essential"

Adults and children are prescribed injections into a vein of 5-10 ml per day. In difficult situations - from 10 to 20 ml per day. Up to 10 ml of the drug can be administered at a time. If this drug is administered to the patient in a diluted form, then it is advisable to use the patient’s own blood and mix the drug in a ratio of 1: 1.

Intravenous injections are usually given usually 10 days. As a maintenance therapy, the patient subsequently takes capsules.

The general course of treatment with this medication is from 3 to 6 months.

Side Effects of Essentiale

It is very rare that a patient may develop diarrhea when taken in high doses of this drug. In general, this medicine is well tolerated by patients, without causing them any more disorders.

Cost of Essential

The price of this medication depends on the form of its release. So, for a solution for intravenous administration (5 ampoules of 5 ml) you need to pay about 600 rubles. And for 30 capsules you have to give about 450 rubles. As you can see, the price of the drug "Essentiale" is much higher than the medication "Carsil".

Storage, conditions of dispensing from pharmacies of the drug "Essential"

The shelf life of this product is 3 years. Capsules should be stored at a temperature not exceeding 25 degrees, and the ampoules in the refrigerator (from +2 to +8 degrees). This remedy is released only by prescription.

karsil forte analogues

Which medicine to choose?

To the question: which is better - “Karsil” or “Essential”, it is definitely impossible to answer. It all depends on a particular disease. So, if we are talking about toxic lesions of the liver of varying severity, then it would be better to carry out therapy with the "Karsil" medication. If the patient has multiple liver lesions or fatty hepatosis, which requires accelerating the growth of new cells, then it is better to buy Essentiale.

Similarities and differences between the two drugs

Both medicines are based on natural ingredients. Also, both drugs belong to the group of hepatoprotectors, the function of which is to protect liver cells from various factors. This is where the similarity of these drugs ends. But what are their differences?

  1. Dosage of drugs. Karsil capsules are usually taken within 3 months, and Essential tablets are often given for up to 6 months.
  2. Contraindications The drug "Karsil" is prohibited for children under 12 years old, pregnant women, as well as breast-feeding mothers. A capsule of "Essential", on the contrary, can be assigned to these categories of the population.
  3. Means "Carsil" is available in only one form - in the form of capsules. At the same time, the Essentiale medicine is dispensed from pharmacies in two forms: capsules and injection.
  4. Price. The cost of the Karsil medication is much less than its counterpart.
  5. Effects on the body. Since the Essentiale preparation is available in the form of ampoules for injection, as well as in the form of capsules, unlike the Karsil preparation, it activates the action of beneficial substances on the affected areas of the liver faster.
  6. Terms of sale. The drug "Karsil" is dispensed without a prescription, while the drug "Essential" can be purchased only if there is an official paper from the doctor.

Now you know everything about the “Karsil” medicine: price, analogues, rules of use, terms of sale of this medicine. They determined that there is an excellent substitute for this tool, which is called "Essential". Although this medicine has some advantages over Karsil capsules, it also has a major drawback - its price, which many cannot afford. In general, only a doctor will help determine which drug is best to buy. If a specialist prescribed the medication “Karsil” or “Essential”, then you need to purchase exactly the tool that the doctor recommended.


All Articles