The drugs "Protargol" and "Sialor" are quite effective agents for the treatment of the common cold. Very often, patients wonder about Sialor and Protargol - what is the difference? In fact, they are not much different from each other. However, for some people, these differences can be quite significant.
Composition and form of release of Protargol
In the pharmacy you can find both powder and liquid drops of this drug. It is based on silver, which has antimicrobial properties. The action of this element was known in ancient times. Metal ions fight bacteria well and provide a sufficiently long positive effect.
Beneficial features
This drug is used to treat upper respiratory tract infections, genitourinary infections, as well as eye diseases of a viral or bacterial origin. It is also used for inflammation of the middle ear as an additional tool for complex treatment. It perfectly relieves puffiness and stops any inflammatory process.
The shelf life of the drug is 24 months. The product is stored at a temperature not exceeding 25 degrees. Many patients prefer to keep drops in the refrigerator, considering this place the most convenient.
How to use
Typically, a drug is instilled into the ear, eye or nose in an amount not exceeding two drops at a time. In total, no more than three procedures can be done per day. The course of treatment lasts from one week to ten days. Usually this remedy is very well tolerated, and only in some cases can an allergy occur in the form of redness or burning sensation of the mucous membrane.
To whom it is contraindicated
Due to the fact that the effect of Protargol on the female body and fetus during pregnancy has not yet been studied, it is not recommended to be used in the first and last trimester. In addition, it is also undesirable to use the drug during breastfeeding. Doctors do not recommend using this tool at the same time as drugs that contain the active component papain.
Composition and application
The composition of Sialor and Protargol is markedly different. The drug "Sialor" is a drop for the nose, which contains the active substance xylometazoline. It can be used to treat children from a very young age. As a rule, the liquid is instilled in two drops in each nostril no more than three times a day. From the age of seven, adult patients and children can be instilled with three drops up to four times a day.
Beneficial features
Sometimes patients think that “Sialor” and “Protargol” are one and the same. Not really. As part of Sialor, in addition to the active component, there is an alpha-adrenergic agonist that has a decongestant property. Because of this, drops have a vasoconstrictor effect.
Some people do not tolerate this remedy, as it causes them a headache. However, thanks to alpha-adrenergic agonist, a rather rapid decongestant effect occurs, and for some time the secretion of mucus completely stops.
Recommendations for use
Before burying your nose with Sialor, the instructions for use for children advise you to rinse your nasal passages with warm water and salt or just blow your nose thoroughly. The course of treatment should not last more than one week. If the drug does not help, then you should switch to other means of treatment. Moderate use of the drug usually does not affect the reaction rate when working with complex mechanisms or driving a car.
Contraindications and side effects
When comparing "Protargol" and "Sialor" very often indicate side effects of the latter. For example, it is highly undesirable to use it simultaneously with antidepressants. In addition, due to the vasoconstrictor effect, the drug causes a headache. It can not be used for people with thrombophlebitis and other vascular diseases. The effect after using "Sialor" lasts, as a rule, at least twelve hours. It is highly undesirable to exceed the permissible norm, so as not to cause side effects.
The main differences between drugs
Between the preparations "Sialor" and "Protargol" what is the difference? Both remedies do a good job with acute or chronic rhinitis, however, they have a significant difference when used and in contraindications. For example, Sialor contains a number of limitations due to the vasoconstrictor effect. While Protargol raises a number of questions about effectiveness. Many parents complain that this remedy is practically useless in case of acute cold and poorly reduces swelling.
Unfortunately, silver ions do not have sufficient properties in the fight against bacteria. Especially if a child or an adult has a viral disease. In such cases, Protargol is completely powerless.
Benefits of drugs
Nevertheless, “Sialor” is a rather convenient tool. It is available in the form of tablets that can be dissolved in water and used not only for colds, but also for washing the eyes. Preparing a solution is quite simple. For this, the package along with the instruction contains all the necessary components, including a container with liquid, a blister with a tablet and a bottle with a dropper for nasal instillation.
The tablet is removed from the blister and placed in a vial. Then water is poured from the container and gently shaken. The resulting tool is used for its intended purpose. Therefore, when asked about Sialor and Protargol, what is the difference between these drugs, many patients indicate the convenience in using the first of them.
The drug "Protargol" is often recommended by doctors as a fixing agent when the acute stage of rhinitis ends. Users note some similarities between the two drugs when used. In their opinion, they are equally bitter in the throat after the drops fall into the nose. Because of the convenience, some parents like Sialor more.
Popular analogues
What to choose - “Sialor” or “Protargol”? What is the difference? Is it possible to replace? Patients are often interested in analogues of these drugs. The following drugs are commonly used:
- Drops for nose "Salin", which contains the active component sodium chloride. This Italian drug copes with any infection and cleanses your breath well. It can be used in both acute and chronic rhinitis. As a rule, Salin is instilled one drop in each nostril for three or four days.
- Spray "Eucosaline" is sold in convenient bottles and also contains sodium chloride. This tool is tolerated quite well, and the only contraindication to use is individual intolerance to the components. The product is stored at a temperature of no more than 25 degrees for 24 months.
- The drug "Aquamax" well cleanses the nasal passages and is used to eliminate excessive dryness in the nose. It is part of the comprehensive treatment of various types of rhinitis. It can be used during the first and last trimester of pregnancy, as well as during lactation.
In addition, Nosalen and No-Sol drops proved to be quite good. In a word, if necessary, you can replace "Sialor" and "Protargol" with other drugs. The price of Sialor and Protargol is slightly different. For example, in the first drug, it ranges from 316 rubles to 340. Drops of Protargol are slightly cheaper. Their average price is only 110 rubles.